The road was an engineering triumph, with some sections constructed to a notably high standard. However, it was not an unqualified success in practical terms. Apart from the steep grades, there was a lack of water and horse feed along the route. The road quickly fell into disuse with the development of alternative means of getting to the Hunter Valley, such as steamships and newer roads. Much of the road fell into total disuse while other parts were absorbed into the urban and rural road network.